Jay Butler
Mr. Horner
2-12-15
Literature
Animal Farm and the books we have read previously this year, all have something similar. This something is equality. Equality plays a very important role in Animal Farm, as well as in previous books we read: Harrison Bergeron andThe Lottery. But equality is not always good. Harrison Bergeron talks about what it would be like if every one had equal traits.
In Harrison Bergeron, Harrison has amazing athletic abilities but the government thinks it is unfair to all the other people who do not have this ability. So the government makes Harrison handicapped and requires him to carry heavy items that weigh him down. The agents who work for the government in Harrison Bergeron are not handicapped, so they are technically not following the rule that everyone must be equal. The government in Animal Farm establishes the SEVEN COMMANDMENTS but does not follow the Commandments.
In Lord Of The Flies Ralph wants everyone's rights to be equal. He finds a conch shell and who ever is holding it gets to talk. Jack thinks he should be the leader, but if he was to be the leader, he would make everyone's rights unfair. Jack would act like he was the greatest. The rules which were made to keep everything fair were also broken, like the high-ranked characters do in Animal Farm.
In The Lottery, Tessie was upset when a child got the black dot. So the judge let Tessie have a chance to draw for the black dot. The boy was not chosen to have a the black dot, but Tessie got it. A lady said "we all had the same chance Tessie". So every one had the same chance to get the dot.
This essay showed how equality has different meanings. Equality could be good if there is a pie and every one gets the same size piece. However, if everything was completely equal in life, we would live like Harrison Bergeron and no one would want to be handicapped. So over all people think differently about how equality effects people in life.
Your first two paragraphs make good arguments, Jay. In your third: is equality the same as fairness? Does Ralph aim at equality in LOTF?
ReplyDeletePara 4: I don't recall Tessie's being upset about a child getting a black dot. Please clarify.
Grammar suggestions: Titles of books should be in italics (or if you are writing a hard copy, underlined). Titles of short stories, such as "Harrison Bergeron" and "The Lottery" should be placed in quotation marks.
Overall: a good effort.